Restoration of Folk Murals of Shia’s Religion in Iran: The Influences of the Expectations of their Public Audiences and the Preference of the Values of these Paintings on the Process of Reconstruction

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph. D Candidate in Conservation and Restoration of Cultural and Historical Objects, Isfahan University of Arts, Faculty of Conservation and Restoration, Isfahan, Iran.

2 Associate Professor of Conservation and Restoration of Cultural and Historical Objects, Isfahan University of Arts, Faculty of Conservation and Restoration, Isfahan, Iran.

Abstract

Murals of Shia’s history from the late Safavid period and its culmination from the Qajar period onwards as the historical religious culture of the public in religious historical sites to this day by continuity of use, cause the emergence of a special attitude to the outstanding features of these paintings and the expectations of their general audience in the restoration. The majority of the murals of such buildings were based on Shiite religion traditions. Overall, the combination of a number of factors namely the significance of the values that have made a connection with the target audience of the heritages in use and the focus on their perception in the last decades, led to this study to pursue this goal to investigate the effects of the characteristics of folk-art paintings in Iran and the needs of their audiences, on their perception of the narrative during the reconstruction. This research has been done due to the development of value-based approaches in the restoration’s contemporary theory at the international level and the importance of the sociological issue of audiences, and the lack of academic research in this field in Iran. This article used purposeful and semi-structured interview techniques with 13 experts and library studies in a qualitative method and performed the analysis with the Colaizzi phenomenological approach by categorizing the interviews. The findings led to the achievement of 6 auxiliary categories and 11 subcategories, that auxiliary categories as factors affecting the reconstruction of the loss of religious-narrative folk murals based on value preference and the expectations of their general audience are:1)the place of special values of folk-art paintings of Shia’s history, 2)factors affecting the perception of public audiences 3)factors affecting the mental retelling of public audiences 4)definition of target audiences(stakeholders),5)the expectations of the public audience from reading the images of historical-religious narratives, and 6)the expectations of the public audience from the restoration and reconstruction of the paintings;

Keywords


  1. Afhami, R; & Sharifi Mehrjerdi, A, 2011, “Art and artists in Qajar Persia”, Ketab-e-Mah-e-Honar, 24-33. [In Persian]

    Aflaki, A, 2005, “A research on aesthetic of the relation between image and narrative literature”, Bagh-e Nazar journal, 21-26. [In Persian]

    Afshari, M, 2007, "Imaginary paintings (Khialinegari), the basis of iconography in the modern concept”, Ketab-e-Mah-e-Honar, 38-44. [In Persian]

    Ahmadi, B, 1995, Truth and beauty, lessons of philosophy of art, Tehran, Markaz. [In Persian]

    Akhavian, M, 2012, The social origin of Islamic murals in north of Iran, Doctoral dissertation in Art research, Shahed university. [In Persian]

    Akhavian, M, 2017, “Reproduction of the Frescoes on the Walls of the “Naqshin” Holly Tombs in the Region of Guilan”, Negareh journal, 71-82. [In Persian]

    Alexander, V, 2010, “Reception Approaches (Approaches to Understanding)”, Binab Journal, 106-125. [In Persian]

    AliMohammadi Ardakani, J, 2013, Synchronization of Qajar literature and painting, Tehran, Yassavoli. [In Persian]

    Anasori, J, 2005, “Iranian Art and The Impact of Shiism on Its Types”, Shi’a Studies Journal, 85-113. [In Persian]

    Ansari, M; Azamzadeh, M; & Pourmand, H, 2012, “Religious Concepts in the Local Paintings of Tekyeh Places in Mazandaran”, Islamic Art journal, 73-90. [In Persian]

    Aryanpour, A, 1975, Sociology of Art. Tehran, Book Association for Students of the Faculty of Fine Arts, University of Tehran. [In Persian]

    Avrami, E; & others(eds), 2019, Values in heritage management emerging approaches and research, Los angeles, the Getty conservation مؤسسه.

    AzamZadeh, M, 2012, Conceptual analysis of native and traditional motifs in the architecture of Tekyehs of Mazandaran, Doctoral dissertation in Art research, Tarbiat Modares university. [In Persian]

    Azhand, y, 2010, Iranian Painting, Tehran, Samt. [In Persian]

    Baillie, B, 2006, “conservation of the sacred at angkorwat”, Conservation and management of archaeological sites, vol 8 no3,123-131.

    Balbas, D, 2016, “To be preserved or to be replaced?”, studies in conservation, vol61, no2, 319-320.

    Belting, H, 2016, “Iconic Presence”, Material Religion, Vol 12, no2,235-237.

    Boon NeeLoh, J, 2002, “Decision from indecision: conservation of thangka significance, perspectives and approaches”, Journal of conservation and museum studies, vol 8,1-5.

    Brace, N; Kemp, R; & Snelgar, R, 2006, Spss for Psychologists, Tehran, Agah. [In Persian]

    Brajer, I, 2008, “Values and opinions of the general public on wall paintings and their restoration”, Studies in conservation, vol53, no1,33-38.

    Bulookbashi, A, 1998, Iran coffee-houses, Tehran, Iran Cultural Studies. [In Persian]

    Cather, S, 2007, “Issues in the conservation of mural paintings”, In: kazuya yamauchi, and others(eds), mural paintings of the silk road, London, archetype,173-174.

    Chalipa, K, 2011, Investigation of the Impact of National Religious Art and Literature on Imaginary paintings (Khialinegari), Doctoral dissertation in Art research, Shahed university. [In Persian]

    Coccia, M; & Eugenie, K, 2009, “Two interventions on devotional paintings: religious devotion”, Kermes: la rivista del restauro, vol22, no. 73, 45-50

    Cotte, S, 2008, “Conservation of thangkas”, Proceedings of the forum on the conservation of thangkas, special session of the icom-cc 15th triennial conference, India, ICOM-CC,21-29.

    Da Costa, A, 2006, “Christian sacred art”, Studies in conservation, Vol 51, issue 3, 7-11.

    De la torre, M, 2005, “part one: project background”, In: De la torre, M; & others(eds), heritage values in site management, los angeles, the Getty conservation institute.

    De la torre, M, 2013, “Values and heritage conservation”, Heritage & society, Vol 6, issue 2, 155-166.

    Demas, M, 2002, “planning for conservation and management of archaeological sites”, In: Teutonico, J.M; & Palumbo, G, (eds), management planning for archaeological sites, los angeles, the Getty conservation institute.

    Edward, K; & Welch, T, 2011, “The extension of colaizzi’s method of phenomenological enquiry”, contemporary nurse, vol39, no2, 163-171.

    Fadavi, M, 1995, “Origin of human art and Islamic art”, Honar-Ha-Ye Ziba Journal, 6-8. [In Persian]

    Faranda, F, 2007, “Longiano's cross: notes and considerations for the history of conservation”, Conservation science in cultural heritage, No 7, 321-349.

    GhafarAdli, A, 2011, “Reader/Reading: Reader-Oriented Theory”, Theater Journal, 107-126. [In Persian]

    Ghasemi, J, 2005, “A variety of religious aesthetic experiences”, Ziba Shenakht Journal, 65-84. [In Persian]

    Goodarzi(Dibaj), M, 2005, History of Iranian Painting from the Beginning to Present, Tehran, Samt. [In Persian]

    Habib, F, 2010, “Human Aspects of Traditional Iranian Urban Space”, In: The Proceedings of 1st & 2nd Conference on Anthropology of Art, Tehran, Matn. [In Persian]

    Habib, M, 2007, A History of Literary Criticism, Londen, Wiley-Blackwell.

    Hauser, A, 1977, The Extent and Limitation of Sociology of Art and Literature, Tehran, Toos. [In Persian]

    Hejrati Tolouei, M, 2015, “Comparative research on visual signs of Guilan shrines with lithographic images”, MA Thesis in Painting, Islamic Azad University Central Tehran. [In Persian]

    Henderson, J; & Nakamoto, T, 2016, “Dialogue in conservation decision making”, studies in conservation, Vol 61, No2, 67-78.

    Hooshangi, L; & Gholamian, R, 2015, “Painting and iconography: the manifestation of religious art among Shiites and Orthodox Christians”, Marefat-e Adyan Journal, 7-32. [In Persian]

    Hosseini Rad, A; & AzizZadegan, M, 2011, “The Impact of Ta’Ziyeh [A Religious Passion Theater] On Religious Wall-Painting of Qajar Period”, Research Letter of Visual Arts Journal, 31-44. [In Persian]

    Hosseini, B, 2017, Explanation of Persian mural-paintings' Values Approaching World Inscription of Immovable Heritage and Codification of Conservation Principles, Doctoral dissertation in Conservation and Restoration of Historical Properties, Art university of Isfahan. [In Persian]

    Houbart, C; & Dawans, S, 2019, “Conservation ethics today”, In: Schädler-Saub, U; & Szmygin, B(eds), international scientific committee on theory and philosophy of conservation and restoration, Florence – Lublin, Lublin university of technology.

    IsaZadeh, P, 2013, The Forty Sessin, Rasht, Farhang-e Ilia. [In Persian]

    Javani. A; & KazemiNezhad, H, 2016, “Investigation of the Features of Shiite Iconography”, Shi’a Studies, 27-46. [In Persian]

    Javari, M; & Hamidi, A, 2007, “A Review of the Reader-Oriented Theories in the 20th Century”, Adab Pazhuhi Journal, 143-176. [In Persian]

    Kousari, M, 2012, “The Shiite Art in Iran”, Sociological Journal of Art and Literature, 7-36. [In Persian]

    Loulanski, T, 2006, “Revising the concept for cultural heritage”, International journal of cultural property, vol13 no2, 207–233.

    Mahmoudi, F; & Tavousi, M, 2012, “Ritual – Religious Identity of "Ta'ziyeh" and Ashura in Mazandaran's Visual Arts”, National Studies Journal, 67-92. [In Persian]

    MahmoudiNejad, A, 2009, The Murals of the Tombs in Guilan, Rasht, Farhang-e Ilia. [In Persian]

    Marasi, M; Nadalian, A; & MoeinAdini, M, 2014, “A Study of the Concept of Style and its Role in Folk Art”, Culture communication studies journal, 87-110. [In Persian]

    Mason, R; & Avrami, E, 2000, “Heritage values and challenges of conservation planning”, In: Teutonico, J.M; & Palumbo, G(Eds), management planning for archaeological sites, Los angeles, Getty publications.

    Mason, R, 2002,Assessing values in conservation planning”, In: De la torre, M(Editor), assessing the values of cultural heritage, Los angeles, the Getty conservation institute.

    Meghdadi, B, 2005, “Literary Criticism in the Field of Audience Analysis”, Honar Quarterly Journal, 8-27. [In Persian]

    MirKhandan, H, 2012, “A critical review of the philosophical theory of Gadamer's hermeneutics”, Ma'rifat-i Farhangi Ejtemaii Journal, 68-85. [In Persian]

    Mirzai Mehr, A, 2007, The Paintings of The Iranian Holy Shrines, Tehran, Iranian Academy of the Arts. [In Persian]

    Mohseni, M, 2007, A Study in Iranian Cultural Sociology, Tehran, Research Center for Culture, Art and Communications. [In Persian]

    Moridi, M; & TaghiZadegan, M, 2006, “A Sociological Study of The Structural Elements of the Art System”, Journal of Social Sciences, 163-191. [In Persian]

    Mousavilar, A; & Khahpour, M, 2015, “Wall Drawings of the Shrines of Pinchah Village in Guilan and Analysis of the Contents”, Bagh-e Nazar Journal, 13-18. [In Persian]

    Munos Vinas, S, 2010, Contemporary Theory of Conservation, Isfahan, Goldasteh. [In Persian]

    NaghiZadeh, M, 2001, “Religion's usage of art, the interrelationship between religion and art”, Religious Art Journal, 112-129. [In Persian]

    Nasri, A, 2004, “Elements of Understanding in Gadamer’s Thought”, Philosophy of Religion Research (Namah-i Hikmat) Journal, 55-65. [In Persian]

    Noroozitalab, A, 2010, “An Inquiry into (morphology) Iconology of Artwork and Meaning Perception”, Bagh-e Nazar Journal, 69-86. [In Persian]

    1. Jaktaji, M, 2008, The Folk Beliefs Concerning the Shrines f Guilan, Rasht, Farhang-e Ilia. [In Persian]

    Pope, A; & Ackerman, P, 2008, A New Survey of Persian Art, Tehran, Elmi Farhangi Publishing Co. [In Persian]

    Poulios, I, 2014, “Discussing strategy in heritage conservation living heritage approach as an example of strategic innovation”, Journal of cultural heritage management and sustainable development, vol4 no1,16-34.

    Ravadrad A, 2006, The Place of Economics in The Sociology of Art, Binanb Journal, 48-63. [In Persian]

    RazAfsha, M, 2000, Investigation of The Special Place of Art Perception and Aesthetics, Religious Art Journal, 105-118. [In Persian]

    Rima Makaryk, I, 2005, Encyclopedia of Contemporary Literary Theory, Tehran, Agah. [In Persian]

    Sanders, C, 2003, “application of colaizzi’s method”, contemporary nurse, vol14, no3, 292-302.

    Sanjay, d, 2003, “Challenges in the context of the living sacred tradition of mahayana Buddhism”, studies in conservation, vol51, no2, 151-155.

    Schwa´b, Z, 2003, “Mind the Gap: The Impact of Wolfgang Iser’s Reader-Response Criticism on Biblical Studies”, Literature and Theology, Vol17, No2, 170-181.

    Seif, H, 2001, Persian Murals, Tehran, Soroush press. [In Persian]

    Selden, R, 2005, A reader’s guide to contemporary literary theory, London, Pearson Education Limited.

    Shad Ghazvini, P, 2018, The sacred painting in the mausoleums of the eastern of Guilan, Tehran, Ketab-e-Sabz. [In Persian]

    Shadrokh, S; & Rahmati, H, 2017, Reflection of different aspects of folk arts in the paintings of holy shrines in Lahijan in the Qajar period, The history of Islamic culture and civilization journal, 85-106. [In Persian]

    Solomidou-Ieronymidou, M, & Rickerby, S, 2010, “the byzantine and post-byzantine wall paintings of Cyprus”, Studies in conservation, Vol 55 no2,231-236.

    Stovel, H, 2005, “Introduction”, In: Stovel, H; & others, (eds), Conservation of Living Religious Heritage, Rome, ICCROM.

    Sully, D; & Pombo Cardoso, I, 2014, “Painting Hinemihi by numbers”, Studies in conservation, vol59 no3,180-193.

    Tabatabaei, Z, 2015, Modeling perception and reception of aesthetic and artistic values for conservation artistic heritage (based on approaches of mullasadra’s philosophy and gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutic), Doctoral dissertation in Conservation and Restoration of Historical Properties, Art university of Isfahan. [In Persian]

    Tashakkori, A; & Teddie, Ch, 2010, Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioral Research, Tehran, University of Tehran. [In Persian]

    Taylor, J; & Cassar, M, 2008, “Representation and intervention”, Studies in conservation, vol53, no1,15-19.

    UNESCO Education Sector, 2004, The Plurality of Literacy and Its Implications for Policies and Programs: Position Paper, Paris, UNESCO.

    UNESCO Education Sector, 2017, Reading the past, writing the future, Paris, UNESCO.

    Valipour, A; & Ghazizadeh, Kh, 2015, “A Study of Distinctions and Similarities in Coffeehouse Painting and Comic Strips”, Negareh Journal, 79-91. [In Persian]

    Wijesuriya, G, 2005, ”The past is in the present: perspectives in caring for buddhist heritage sites in seri lanka”, In: Stovel, H; & others(eds), conservation of living religious heritage, Rome, ICCROM.

    Wilson, T, 2009, Understanding Media Users: From Theory to Practice, Londen, Wiley-Blackwell.

Volume 13, Issue 4 - Serial Number 28
September 2022
Pages 117-140
  • Receive Date: 12 August 2020
  • Revise Date: 28 October 2020
  • Accept Date: 01 March 2021
  • First Publish Date: 20 February 2022