Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate Archaeology Department, Literature and Humanities Faculty, Tehran University.

2 Professor Department of Archaeology, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Since the onset of the Enlightenment in the early 18th century, and the subsequent establishment of museums, galleries, and private collections, the acquisition of cultural artifacts to populate these institutions became imperative. However, this period also witnessed the emergence of counterfeit works, crafted in collaboration with specialists across various disciplines. A crucial inquiry arises regarding the identification of the methods and techniques employed by forgers, the recent surge in counterfeit production, and the detrimental impact of such works on archaeological studies and museum activities. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive examination of counterfeit works, tracing their origins in Iran, elucidating the typology of counterfeit objects, detailing the methods of forgery, and analyzing their dissemination to target audiences. Through a combination of library research and field studies, this investigation reveals that counterfeit works exploit historical and cultural significance, often leveraging contemporary scientific knowledge. The lack of precise discernment by target groups regarding these counterfeit works has facilitated their creation and distribution across three primary levels: 1) individuals seeking to amass wealth, 2) domestic enthusiasts of historical and cultural artifacts, and 3) galleries and foreign museums

Keywords

Abdi Kamiar.2002. “moarefie ketabe ashiaye taghalobi”, bastanshenasi va tarikh, no 31, pp 77-78.[in Persian].
Abolala, sodavar.2010. “baresi farmane eighori abosaeid bahadorkhan va ertebate an ba kashfe ieki az jaalhaie tarikhi safaveie” nameie baharestan, no 16, safahate ,pp197 -210.[in Persian].
Afshar Eiraj.2007. “mamoriate keristian sene danmarki baraie kharide noskheie khati”, nameie baharestan, pp 469.[in Persian].
Aghdashlo Aidin.2001. “nokati chand dar babe karshenasi asare honari irani dar kharej”, majmoeie maghalate motaleate irani, no 5, sazemane farhang va ertebatate eslami, moavenate pagoheshi va amozeshe markaze motaleate farhangi va beinolmalali, pp 264-276.[in Persian].
Ahmadi Kamran, Bahrololomi Franak.2017.“majmoe maghalate avalin hamaiesh taeein esalat ashiaie tarikhi farhangi va honari”, pagoheshgahe mirase farhangi, sanaie dasti va gardeshgari, pp 9.[in Persian].
Aiazi Sori.2003. sarsanjaghhaie mefraghie lorestan dar mozeie melie iran, Tehran, sazemane mirase farhangie keshvar.[in Persian].
Azimi Habibolah, Hashemi asl Helia.2015. “baresi anvae jaal va tazvir dar noskhehaie khati ba estenad be nemonehaii az an” aeyneie miras, no 56, pp 265-291.[in Persian].
Bahrololomi Faranak.2002. “taeeine escalate asnad va nosakhe khati ba estefade az raveshhaie elmi va azmaieshgahi”, nameie baharestan, no 2, pp 251-256.[in Persian].
Connan,Jacques, et Deshesne.Odile. 1996. LE Bitume A Suse, R eunion des Musees Nationux.
Ebne ekhvah Mohamad ebne ahmad gharashi.1968.Aeine shahrdari dar gharne haftom, teranclator jafare shoar, entesharate boniade farhang iran.[in Persian].
Farahmand Borojeni Hamid.2004. “mavad morede estefade be vasileie negargarane irani dar sadehaie miani”, majmoe maghalate motaleate irani, no 17, pp 35-84.[in Persian].
Ferai Richard Nelson.2002. “ketabhaie eslami sakhtegi az iran”, nameie baharestan, terranclator seied Mohamad ali ahmadi abhari, no 5, pp 193-196.[in Persian].
Ganter an Si, Pol jet.2004.felezkari iran dar dorane hakhamaneshi, ashkani, sasani, teranclator shahram heidarabadian, entesharate ganjine honar.[in Persian].
GHanami Omid.2002. majmoeie ghavanin va moghararate mirase farhangi, sanaie dasti va gardashgari, Tehran, ghalamrove farhang.[in Persian].
Gholam dost Mahtab.2012. “jayeghahe ghanone atighat va hafriate tejari dar bastanshenasi iran”, majmoeie maghalate hashtadomin sale bastanshenasi iran, vol 1 and 2, pp 11-47.[in Persian].
Hasory Ali.1990.”katibehaie jaali”, simorgh,no 3,pp 24-29.[in Persian].
Herman Jorjina.1994. tajdide hayate honar va tamadon dar iran bastan, teranclator mehrdad vahtati, markaze nashre daneshgahi.[in Persian].
KHosravi Leila.2011. tajzie va tahlil ganjine ghare kalmakare lorestan ba takide bar negareha, shekl va fanavari sakhte ashia, daneshkade olome ensani gorohe bastanshenasi daneshgahe tarbiate modares.[in Persian].
KHosravi Leila.2013. ganjineie ghare kalmakare, entesharate pajoheshgahe sazeman mirase farhangi.[in Persian].
Lokonein Veladimir Grygorovich.1993. tamadone iran sasani, teranclator enaiat o alah reza, entesharate elmi va farhangi.[in Persian].
Malekkian Hamid, Nikbar Maziar.2005. “raveshhaye shenasaeie asare badali”, majmoe maghalate haftomin hamaieshe hefazat va maremate ashya tarikhi farhangi va tazeinate vabaste be memari, pajoheshgahe sazemane miras farhangi, pp 204-208.[in Persian].
Maskarela Oskar Wait.2007. “ashiaye honari kavide va nakavide hakhamaneshi”, terancloter kamiare abdi, dore jaded, no 4, pp 73-92.[in Persian].
Maskarela Oskar Wait.2011. “Zivieh va Zivieh jaale yek khastgah”, teranclator akrame gholami kheibari va sima miri, bastanpajohi, dore jaded, no 7, pp 97- 114.[in Persian].
Masomi GHolamreza.2044. tarikhche elme bastanshenasi, entesharate samt.[in Persian].
Minovi Mojtaba.2002. “kapos name”, nameie baharestan, vol 5, ketabkhane mozeie markaze asnade majleseshoraie eslami, pp 165-172.[in Persian].
Muscarella Oscar White.2000. The Lie Became Great The Forgery Of Ancient Near Eastern Cultures. Styx publications groningen.
Muscarella Oscar Whith.2012. "An Unholy Quartet: Museum Trustees, Antiquity Dealers, Scientific Experts, and Government Agents", Namvarnameh Papers in Honour Of Mussoud Azarnoush, By Hamid Fahimi and Karim Alizadeh, Tehran, Iran, Nagar, pp475-480.
Muscarella Oscar Whith.1988. Bronze and Iron, Ancient Near Eastern Artifacts in the Metropolitan Museum of Art,The Metropolitan Museum Of Art/Newyork.
Negahban Ezatola.2006. morori bar panjah sal bastanshenasi iran, sazeman mirase farhangi, entesharate sobhane nor.[in Persian].
Negahban Ezatola.1993. hafari haftape dashte khozestan, entesharate sazeman miras farhangi keshvar.[in Persian].
Negahban,Ezato.1984. "Huft tepe Roundels, An Example Of Elamite Art", American Journal Of Archaeology.Vol,88.p,3-10.
Peier Lokok.2003. katibehaie hakhamaneshi, teranclaor nazila khalkhali, farzan.[in Persian].
Ravandi Mohamad Ebne Ali Ebne Soleiman.1954. rahate sodor va aiate sodor dar tarikhe ale Saljogh, tasheie Mohamad eghbal, ba havashie mjtaba minovi, entesharate amir kabir.[in Persian].
Razani Mahdi, Bakhshandefar Hamidreza, Tavakoli Asghar, Nasirzadeh Behnaz.2010.”negahi be jaale mirase farhangi dar iran ba baresi paye cheraghe jaali be sabke salgoghi dar kakh mozeie chehelsotone Esfahan”maremat va pajohesh do faslname maremat ashiaie farhangi, banahaie tarikhi, no 8, pp 7-22..[in Persian].
Razani Mahdi, Nasirzadeh Behnaz.2014. “jaal va taghalob dar asare bastaniva honarhaie tajasomi, mafahim,goneshenasi,sarnevesht ghanoni va raveshhaie baresi “,bargozideh maghalate avalin va dovomin hamaiesh karborde tahlilhaie elmi dar bastansanji va maremat mirase farhangi, daneshgahe honare eslami Tabriz, pp 107-132.[in Persian].
Seied Sadr Abolghasem.2004. daiereatolmaaref honar, Tehran simaie danesh.[in Persian].
Sharp Rolf Narman.1967. farmanhaie shahanshahane hakhamaneshi,daneshkade adabiate daneshgahe Pahlavi shiraz.[in Persian].
Stone Peter,2002, "The rape of Mesopotamia: behind the looting of the Iraq Museum". Pubilic Archaelogy. Vol 8, No 4, p318-381.
Vahtati Ali Akbar.2001. “KHanjar katibedar mozeie iran bastan- asl ya jaal?”, bastan pajohi, no 8, pp 23-26.[in Persian].
Vatandost Rasol.2003-2004-2005-2014. majmoe maghalate 5,6,7,11 hamaiesh hefazat va maremat asar tarikhi va tazeinate vabaste be memari, pajoheshgah sazeman miras farhangi keshvar.[in Persian].
Watson oliver.2004. “fakes and forgeries in Islamic pottery”,Oriente Moderno, pp 517-539.
Yoko Taniguchi, Yoshimitsu Hirao, Yoshiko Shimadzu and Akira Tsuneki, 2002.”The Firest Fake? Imitaion Turquoise Beads Recovered From A Syrian Neolithic Site, Tell el- Kerkh”, Studies in Conservation, vol 47, No 3, Pp 175- 182.